Best of Assistant Generals: Siege PvP

* This ranking is for Assistant Generals.
Click here to see
– Main Generals Ranking (Siege)
– Generals Combination Recommendation
– Generals Combination Compatibility List

7/12/2024 – added Theodosius I.
5/31/2024 – added skin buff to Melisande.
4/19/2024 – added Gunther, Melisande.
3/3/2024 – “Covenant” buff was applied and the entire ranking was updated.
2/8/2024 – added Mu Guiying.
12/15/2023 – added John Hunyadi.
10/27/2023 – added Raimondo.
9/1/2023 – added Kleos(+Skin).
8/4/2023 – added Pallas, Kleos.
5/26/2023 – added Edward Teach.
3/4/2023 – added Ranking when reinforcing an ally’s castle.
3/3/2023 – added John Churchill.
12/30/2022 – added Zucca, Mason Weaver.
10/20/2022 – added Septimius Severus.

Assumptions

Compatibility with the main general

It is not possible to make an absolute ranking, since the compatibility with the main general must also be taken into account.

The rankings in this article do not include as a ranking factor who can be paired with whom.
Basically, the rankings are based solely on the height of the buffs.

Please also refer to the “General’s Combination Compatibility List” in this article.

Evaluation Criteria

The following 3 types.

  • Evaluation 1 – Considers only Buffs
    • Add up the percentages of the 5 types of buffs: attack, defense, HP, march size, and rally capacity.
  • Evaluation 2 – Considers Skill Book limitations
    • If there is a skill book that cannot be used, points are deducted from the Evaluation 1 score.
    • For example: if an attack skill book is not available, -25.
  • Evaluation 3 – Considers Debuffs
    • If a general has a debuff, its percentage is added to the score of Evaluation 2.
    • If debuffs for all types of troops, the debuff value x4.

Since I think that the most practical is evaluation 2, the ranking is in the order of the highest evaluation 2.

The ranking of the evaluation 1 and 3 can be seen by rearranging the table in the article. Please refer to it if you are interested.

Ranking of Assistants requiring Dragon & Spiritual Beast

Since it is not difficult to assign a Spiritual beast to an assistant, it is included in the ranking.

Assigning dragons to assistants is not practical for most players, so they have been excluded from the rankings.

However, they are included in the table, so if you are interested, please refer to that list.

4 types of ranking

The ranking is divided into the following four categories (2 x 2)

Category 1: with or without Marching Buff

  • A) for March & Rally
    • With Marching buff
  • B) for Reinforce to an ally’s keep & Wall Defender
    • Without Marching buff

Some buffs that each general has are not valid if they are used as reinforcements to an ally’s keep or if they are made defenders of their own keep. (For more information: Buff / Debuff – Basic Guide)

In other words, some generals have “march/rally and “Reinforcements to an ally’s keep/Defenders” have very different performances.

For this reason, the ranking is divided between these 2 types.

Category 2: with or without Specialty & Covenant

  • 1) Basic skills only
    • Mainly for F2P (Free to Play) or players who pay a little.
  • 2) Basic skills + Specialty & Covenant
    • Mainly for players with heavy payer.

Each general’s performance depends largely on his ability to maximize the 4 specialties & Covenant. And it is difficult to maximize all unless you are a heavy payer. (Reference : Specialty Guide)

Therefore, the ranking is divided into two categories: without specialties/covenant and with specialties/covenant.

A) for March & Rally

= With Marching Buffs. (Reference: Buff / Debuff – Basic Guide)

A-1) Basic skills only

Mainly for F2P (Free to Play) or players who pay a little.

Specialties are not included.

Does not include additional basic skills added by ascending. (They do not add up due to the specifications.)

Covenant are not included.

1. Melisande

  • With Skin
  • Score: 138
  • Attack 50% / Defense 40% / HP 40% / March Size 8% / Rally Size 0%
  • Without Skin
  • Score: 128
  • Attack 40% / Defense 40% / HP 40% / March Size 8% / Rally Size 0%

2. Gunther

  • With Skin + Spiritual Beast
  • Score: 130
  • Attack 45% / Defense 45% / HP 40% / March Size 0% / Rally Size 0%
  • With Spiritual Beast
  • Score: 120
  • Attack 45% / Defense 45% / HP 30% / March Size 0% / Rally Size 0%
  • Without Spiritual Beast
  • Score: 90
  • Attack 45% / Defense 45% / HP 0% / March Size 0% / Rally Size 0%

3. Kleos

  • With Skin
  • Score: 102
  • Attack 40% / Defense 0% / HP 50% / March Size 12% / Rally Size 0%
  • Without Skin
  • Score: 92
  • Attack 40% / Defense 0% / HP 40% / March Size 12% / Rally Size 0%

4. Pallas

  • With Skin + Spiritual Beast
  • Score: 100
  • Attack 55% / Defense 35% / HP 10% / March Size 0% / Rally Size 0%
  • With Spiritual Beast
  • Score: 90
  • Attack 45% / Defense 35% / HP 10% / March Size 0% / Rally Size 0%

5. Theodosius I

  • Score: 98
  • Attack 45% / Defense 45% / HP 0% / March Size 8% / Rally Size 0%

Table (A-1) March/Rally – Basic Skills only

GeneralsBuff TypeAtkDefHPMarch SizeRally CapacityDebuffSkill Book LimitScore 1Score 2Score 3
Theodosius IMarch4545080989898
Gunther (+Skin
+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
March45454000Ranged Attack -10%
Siege Attack -10%
130130150
Gunther
(+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
March45453000120120120
GuntherMarch4545000909090
Melisande (+Skin)Basic50404080Siege HP -10%138138148
MelisandeBasic40404080128128128
Mu GuiyingBasic45202000can’t attach Atk856060
John HunyadiMarch45151500757575
Raimondo (+Skin)Basic4535000Ranged HP -20%
Siege HP -20%
can’t attach Atk805595
RaimondoBasic4525000can’t attach Atk704545
Pallas (+Skin
+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
March55351000Ranged HP -20%
Siege HP -20%
100100140
Pallas
(+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
March45351000909090
PallasMarch3535000707070
Kleos (+Skin)March40050120Ranged Def -20%
Siege Def -20%
102102142
KleosMarch40040120929292
Edward Teach
(+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
Basic4030000707070
Edward TeachBasic3030000606060
John ChurchillMarch3000012424242
Mason Weaver
(+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
Basic20252500707070
Mason WeaverBasic200000202020
ZuccaMarch4003500757575
PetronasMarch4020000606060
Septimius SeverusBasic3502000can’t attach Atk553030
Surena (+Dragon)Basic400000can’t attach Atk401515
SurenaBasic250000can’t attach Atk2500
Philip IIMarch2500010353535
Ramesses IIBasic2020000404040
Ulysses S. Grant
(+Dragon)
Basic300000303030
Ulysses S. GrantBasic150000151515
NapoleonMarch300000303030
Matthias IMarch200050252525
KhalidBasic200000Atk can
attach Lv4 only
202020
ShermanMarch200000202020
Suleiman the MagnificentBasic150000All type Def -10%151555
William WallaceBasic200000Ground Def -20%202040
Isabella I (+Dragon)March1000100202020
Isabella IMarch100000101010
Emperor Qin ShihuangBasic350000can’t attach Atk351010

A-2) Basic skills + Specialty + Covenant

Mainly for players with heavy payer.

For those who want to compare by the maximum value of assistants buffs.

1. Gunther

  • With Skin & Spiritual Beast
  • Score: 318
  • Attack 123% / Defense 100% / HP 85% / March Size 10% / Rally Size 0%
  • With Spiritual Beast
  • Score: 308
  • Attack 123% / Defense 100% / HP 75% / March Size 10% / Rally Size 0%
  • Without Spiritual Beast
  • Score: 278
  • Attack 123% / Defense 100% / HP 45% / March Size 10% / Rally Size 0%

2. Melisande

  • With Skin
  • Score: 279
  • Attack 116% / Defense 80% / HP 70% / March Size 13% / Rally Size 0%
  • Without Skin
    Score: 269
  • Attack 106% / Defense 80% / HP 70% / March Size 13% / Rally Size 0%

3. Theodosius I

  • Score: 278
  • Attack 125% / Defense 100% / HP 45% / March Size 8% / Rally Size 0%

4. Kleos

  • With Skin
  • Score: 252
  • Attack 100% / Defense 45% / HP 95% / March Size 12% / Rally Size 0%
  • Without Skin
  • Score: 242
  • Attack 100% / Defense 45% / HP 85% / March Size 12% / Rally Size 0%

5. John Hunyadi

  • Score: 250
  • Attack 135% / Defense 50% / HP 65% / March Size 0% / Rally Size 0%
  • Score: 225 (No Covenant)
  • Attack 115% / Defense 50% / HP 60% / March Size 0% / Rally Size 0%

Table (A-2) March/Rally – Basic Skills + Specialty + Covenant

GeneralsBuff TypeAtkDefHPMarch SizeRally CapacityDebuffSkill Book LimitCovenant
Buff
Score 1Score 2Score 3
Theodosius IMarch1251004580Included278278278
Gunther (+Skin
+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
March12310085100Ranged Attack -10%
Siege Attack -10%
Included318318338
Gunther
(+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
March12310075100Included308308308
GuntherMarch12310045100Included278278278
Melisande (+Skin)Basic1168070130All type HP -10%
Siege HP -10%
Included279279329
MelisandeBasic1068070130All type HP -10%Included269269309
Mu GuiyingBasic13035455can’t attach AtkIncluded215190190
John HunyadiMarch135506500[overall] Ranged HP -8%
[overall] Siege HP -8%
Included250250266
Raimondo (+Skin)Basic115801060Ranged HP -20%
Siege HP -20%
can’t attach Atk211186226
RaimondoBasic115701060can’t attach Atk201176176
Pallas (+Skin
+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
March116751060Ranged HP -45%
Siege HP -45%
207207297
Pallas
(+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
March106751060Ranged HP -25%
Siege HP -25%
197197247
PallasMarch9675060Ranged HP -25%
Siege HP -25%
177177227
Kleos (+Skin)March1004595120Ranged Def -20%
Siege Def -20%
252252292
KleosMarch1004585120242242242
Edward Teach
(+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
Basic105503500190190190
Edward TeachBasic95503500180180180
John ChurchillMarch902520620161161161
Mason Weaver
(+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
Basic60252500110110110
Mason WeaverBasic600000606060
ZuccaMarch100355560196196196
PetronasMarch100303500165165165
Septimius SeverusBasic95403060can’t attach Atk171146146
Surena (+Dragon)Basic95304060can’t attach Atk171146146
SurenaBasic80304060can’t attach Atk156131131
Philip IIMarch851020615136136136
Ramesses IIBasic80401000130130130
Ulysses S. Grant
(+Dragon)
Basic76102060112112112
Ulysses S. GrantBasic35102060717171
NapoleonMarch72010160989898
Matthias IMarch70102050105105105
KhalidBasic70102000Atk can
attach Lv4 only
100100100
ShermanMarch6601060Siege HP -26%8282108
Suleiman the
Magnificent
Basic61102000All type Def -20%
All type HP -10%
9191211
William WallaceBasic6603600Ground Def -20%102102122
Isabella I (+Dragon)March60010200909090
Isabella IMarch3001000404040
Emperor Qin ShihuangBasic8136060can’t attach Atk1239898

B) for Reinforce to an ally’s city & Wall Defender

= Without Marching Buffs. (Reference: Buff / Debuff – Basic Guide)

When a reinforcement to “Alliance member’s City”, or a wall defender, the “marching buff” (“when General is leading the army to attack” buff) is disabled.

NOTE: When a reinforcement to “Building”, the “marching buff” is enabled. See section A.

Reinforcement to an alliance member’s keep

B-1) Basic skills only

1. Melisande

  • With Skin
  • Score: 138
  • Attack 50% / Defense 40% / HP 40% / March Size 8% / Rally Size 0%
  • Without Skin
  • Score: 128
  • Attack 40% / Defense 40% / HP 40% / March Size 8% / Rally Size 0%

2. Edward Teach

  • With Spiritual Beast
  • Score: 70
  • Attack 40% / Defense 30% / HP 0% / March Size 0%

2. Mason Weaver

  • With Spiritual Beast
  • Score: 70
  • Attack 20% / Defense 25% / HP 25% / March Size 0%

3. Mu Guiying

  • Score: 60
  • Attack 45% / Defense 20% / HP 20% / March Size 0%
  • Can’t attach Attack Skill Book.

4. Raimondo

  • With Skin
  • Score: 55
  • Attack 45% / Defense 35% / HP 0% / March Size 0%
  • Can’t attach Attack Skill Book.

Table (B-1) Reinforce/Defender – Basic Skills only

GeneralsBuff TypeAtkDefHPMarch SizeDebuffSkill Book LimitScore 1Score 2Score 3
Theodosius IMarch0008888
Gunther (+Skin
+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
March0000Ranged Attack -10%
Siege Attack -10%
0020
Gunther
(+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
March0000000
GuntherMarch0000000
Melisande (+Skin)Basic5040408Siege HP -10%138138148
MelisandeBasic4040408128128128
Mu GuiyingBasic4520200can’t attach Atk856060
John HunyadiMarch0000000
Raimondo (+Skin)Basic453500Ranged HP -20%
Siege HP -20%
can’t attach Atk805595
RaimondoBasic452500can’t attach Atk704545
Pallas (+Skin
+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
March0000Ranged HP -20%
Siege HP -20%
0040
Pallas
(+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
March0000000
PallasMarch0000000
Kleos (+Skin)March001012Ranged Def -20%
Siege Def -20%
222262
KleosMarch00012121212
Edward Teach
(+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
Basic403000707070
Edward TeachBasic303000606060
John ChurchillMarch0000000
Mason Weaver
(+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
Basic2025250707070
Mason WeaverBasic20000202020
ZuccaMarch0000000
PetronasMarch0000000
Septimius SeverusBasic350200can’t attach Atk553030
Surena (+Dragon)Basic40000can’t attach Atk401515
SurenaBasic25000can’t attach Atk2500
Philip IIMarch0000000
Ramesses IIBasic202000404040
Ulysses S. Grant
(+Dragon)
Basic30000303030
Ulysses S. GrantBasic15000151515
NapoleonMarch0000000
Matthias IMarch0005555
KhalidBasic20000Atk can
attach Lv4 only
202020
ShermanMarch0000000
Suleiman the
Magnificent
Basic15000All type Def -10%151555
William WallaceBasic20000Ground Def -20%202040
Isabella I (+Dragon)March00010101010
Isabella IMarch0000000
Emperor Qin ShihuangBasic35000can’t attach Atk351010

B-2) Basic skills + Specialty + Covenant

1. Melisande

  • With Skin
  • Score: 284
  • Attack 116% / Defense 85% / HP 70% / March Size 13% / Rally Size 0%
  • Without Skin
  • Score: 274
  • Attack 106% / Defense 85% / HP 70% / March Size 13% / Rally Size 0%

2. Edward Teach

  • With Spiritual Beast
  • Score: 190
  • Attack 105% / Defense 50% / HP 35% / March Size 0%
  • Without Spiritual Beast
  • Score: 180
  • Attack 95% / Defense 50% / HP 35% / March Size 0%

3. Mu Guiying

  • Score: 180
  • Attack 120% / Defense 35% / HP 45% / March Size 5%
  • Cannot add an Attack Skill Book.
  • Score: 165 (No Covenant)
  • Attack 115% / Defense 30% / HP 40% / March Size 5%
  • Cannot add an Attack Skill Book.

4. Raimondo

  • With Skin
  • Score: 176
  • Attack 105% / Defense 80% / HP 10% / March Size 6%
  • Cannot add an Attack Skill Book.
  • Without Skin
  • Score: 166
  • Attack 105% / Defense 70% / HP 10% / March Size 6%
  • Cannot add an Attack Skill Book.

Table (B-2) Reinforce/Defender – Basic Skills + Specialty + Covenant

GeneralsBuff TypeAtkDefHPMarch SizeDebuffSkill Book LimitCovenant
Buff
Score 1Score 2Score 3
Theodosius IMarch3020108Included686868
Gunther (+Skin
+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
March30201010Ranged Attack -10%
Siege Attack -10%
Included707090
Gunther
(+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
March30201010Included707070
GuntherMarch30201010Included707070
Melisande (+Skin)Basic116857013All type HP -10%
Siege HP -10%
Included284284334
MelisandeBasic106857013All type HP -10%Included274274314
Mu GuiyingBasic12035455can’t attach AtkIncluded205180180
John HunyadiMarch3510250[overall] Ranged HP -8%
[overall] Siege HP -8%
Included606060
Raimondo (+Skin)Basic10580106Ranged HP -20%
Siege HP -20%
can’t attach Atk201176216
RaimondoBasic10570106can’t attach Atk191166166
Pallas (+Skin
+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
March161006Ranged HP -45%
Siege HP -45%
3232122
Pallas (+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)March161006Ranged HP -25%
Siege HP -25%
323282
PallasMarch161006Ranged HP -25%
Siege HP -25%
323282
Kleos (+Skin)March20203012Ranged Def -20%
Siege Def -20%
8282122
KleosMarch20202012727272
Edward Teach
(+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
Basic10550350190190190
Edward TeachBasic9550350180180180
John ChurchillMarch2010206565656
Mason Weaver
(+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
Basic6025250110110110
Mason WeaverBasic60000606060
ZuccaMarch2010206565656
PetronasMarch6010350105105105
Septimius SeverusBasic8540306can’t attach Atk161136136
Surena (+Dragon)Basic8530406can’t attach Atk161136136
SurenaBasic7030406can’t attach Atk146121121
Philip IIMarch5010206868686
Ramesses IIBasic5040100100100100
Ulysses S. Grant
(+Dragon)
Basic7610206112112112
Ulysses S. GrantBasic3510206717171
NapoleonMarch1601016424242
Matthias IMarch5010205858585
KhalidBasic7010200Atk can
attach Lv4 only
100100100
ShermanMarch360106Siege HP -26%525278
Suleiman the
Magnificent
Basic6110200All type Def -20%
All type HP -10%
9191211
William WallaceBasic660360Ground Def -20%102102122
Isabella I (+Dragon)March2001020505050
Isabella IMarch200100303030
Emperor Qin ShihuangBasic713606can’t attach Atk1138888

Related – Other Recommended Generals

Overall
List of Best Generals

Recommended generals are summarized by role, such as battle-oriented and development-oriented.

Recommended Main Generals

For a detailed look at each type of troops, click here.

Recommended Assistant Generals
List of All Generals
List of Generals by Role (+ How to Get)

A comprehensive list of all golden historic generals, over 100 in total, by role.

SHARE

If you found this article useful, I would appreciate a donation.

It will encourage me to update the site.

11

11 Comments

Anonymous

I have a question about the covenant.
There are 4 generals involved in making a covenant, the main general and 3 other generals.
If I complete the covenant, is the buff from the covenant still valid for the other 3 generals?
For example, Melisande is also involved in Gunther’s covenant, so if I complete both covenants, will I get the buffs for both Melissani and Gunther’s covenant?

Thank you for all that you do. Where does raimondo rank with his skin?

Daveheart

Sorry but in italian it’s write that Raimondo’s buffs work only in attack. I didn’t check in english

Dawn Treader

Kleos can take lv 4 siege attack, siege hp and march size. March size must be on Kleos and not other general.

Hello! Thanks for the articles, I found a lot of useful for myself. Kleos can be an assistant for Grant. Book of attack, defense and march size work for Kleos.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

The maximum upload file size: 35 MB. You can upload: image. Drop files here

If you found this article useful, I would appreciate a donation.

It will encourage me to update the site.



The copyright and other intellectual property rights of the game screenshots and images used in the contents of this site belong to TOP GAMES Inc.
This site provides content created independently by evonyguidewiki.com.
Unauthorized use or copying and replication (including translation into other languages) of the data, images, etc. on this site is strictly prohibited.