Best of Assistant Generals: Ranged PvP

* This ranking is for Assistant Generals.
Click here to see
– Main Generals Ranking (Ranged)
– Generals Combination Recommendation
– Generals Combination Compatibility List

3/31/2024 – added Idunn.
3/26/2024 – “Covenant” buff was applied and the entire ranking was updated.
3/22/2024 – added Godfrey of Bouillon.
12/29/2023 – added Marcus Agrippa.
11/17/2023 – added Louis IX.
10/25/2023 – added Maarten Tromp.
9/29/2023 – added Mihai.
7/21/2023 – added Subutai.
5/12/2023 – added Section B, “for Reinforce (to ally’s castle) / Wall Defender”.
4/28/2023 – added Eleanor & Douglas.
2/3/2023 – added Charles XII.
12/30/2022 – added Mason Weaver.
12/16/2022 – added Edward III.
9/23/2022 – added Wallenstein.
8/21/2022 – added Toyotomi Hideyori.

Assumptions

Compatibility with the main general

It is not possible to make an absolute ranking, since the compatibility with the main general must also be taken into account.

The rankings in this article do not include as a ranking factor who can be paired with whom.
Basically, the rankings are based solely on the height of the buffs.

Please also refer to the “General’s Combination Compatibility List” in this article.

Evaluation Criteria

The following 3 types.

  • Evaluation 1 – Considers only Buffs
    • Add up the percentages of the 5 types of buffs: attack, defense, HP, march size, and rally capacity.
  • Evaluation 2 – Considers Buffs & Skill book limitations
    • If there is a skill book that cannot be used, points are deducted from the Evaluation 1 score.
    • For example: if an attack skill book is not available, -25.
  • Evaluation 3 – Considers Buffs & Skill book limitations & Debuffs
    • If a general has a debuff, its percentage is added to the score of Evaluation 2.
    • If debuffs for all types of troops, the debuff value x4.

Since I think that the most practical is evaluation 2, the ranking is in the order of the highest evaluation 2.

The ranking of the evaluation 1 and 3 can be seen by rearranging the table in the article. Please refer to it if you are interested.

Ranking of assistants with dragons attached

Assigning dragons to assistants is not practical for most players, so they have been excluded from the rankings.

However, they are included in the table, so if you are interested, please refer to that list.

4 types of ranking

The ranking is divided into the following four categories (2 x 2)

Category 1: with or without Marching Buff

  • A) for March & Rally
    • With Marching buff
  • B) for Reinforce to an ally’s keep & Wall Defender
    • Without Marching buff

Some buffs that each general has are not valid if they are used as reinforcements to an ally’s keep or if they are made defenders of their own keep. (For more information: Buff / Debuff – Basic Guide)

In other words, some generals have “march/rally and “Reinforcements to an ally’s keep/Defenders” have very different performances.

For this reason, the ranking is divided between these 2 types.

Category 2: with or without Specialty

  • 1) Basic skills only
    • Mainly for F2P (Free to Play) or players who pay a little.
  • 2) Basic skills + Specialty
    • Mainly for players with heavy payer.

Each general’s performance depends largely on his ability to maximize the 4 specialties. And it is difficult to maximize all 4 unless you are a heavy payer. (Reference : Specialty Guide)

Therefore, the ranking is divided into two categories: without specialties and with specialties.

A) for March & Rally

= With Marching Buffs. (Reference: Buff / Debuff – Basic Guide)

A-1) Basic skills only

Mainly for F2P (Free to Play) or players who pay a little.

Specialties are not included.

Does not include additional basic skills added by ascending. (They do not add up due to the specifications.)

1. Marcus Agrippa

  • Score: 100
  • Attack 40% / Defense 30% / HP 30% / March Size 0% / Rally Size 0%

1. James Conrad

  • Score: 100
  • Attack 30% / Defense 35% / HP 35% / March Size 0% / Rally Size 0%

2. Godfrey of Bouillon

  • Score:90
  • Attack 40% / Defense 10% / HP 40% / March Size 0% / Rally Size 0%

2. Mihai

  • Score:90
  • Attack 45% / Defense 45% / HP 0% / March Size 0% / Rally Size 0%

3. Eleanor

  • Score:80
  • Attack 35% / Defense 35% / HP 0% / March Size 10% / Rally Size 0%

Table (A-1) March/Rally – Basic Skills only

GeneralsBuff
Type
AtkDefHPMarch
Size
Rally
Capacity
DebuffSkillbook LimitScore
1
Score
2
Score
3
Godfrey of BouillonBasic40104000909090
IdunnOutcity
Def
450000454545
Marcus AgrippaMarch40303000100100100
Louis IXBasic4045000can’t attach
Atk
856060
MihaiMarch4545000909090
SubutaiBasic40202000can’t attach Atk805555
Maarten Tromp
(at SvS)
March5520000757575
Maarten TrompMarch350000353535
EleanorMarch35350100808080
DouglasMarch250000252525
Douglas
(+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
March4015000555555
Douglas (+Skin
+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
March5015000Ground Def -20%
Mounted Def -20%
6565105
Charles XIIMarch40100100606060
Mason WeaverBasic200000202020
Mason Weaver
(+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
Basic20252500707070
Edward IIIBasic2515000404040
James ConradMarch30353500100100100
Princess KaguyaMarch3503000656565
TomyrisMarch350005404040
Simeon the GreatMarch200000202020
Simeon the Great (+Dragon)March350000353535
Alfred the GreatMarch300000303030
ElektraMarch150000151515
Elektra (+Dragon)March350000353535
WallensteinMarch2500010353535
Toyotomi HideyoriBasic20101000404040
Minamoto no YoshitsuneBasic250000can’t attach Atk2500
Minamoto no Yoshitsune
(+Dragon)
Basic400000can’t attach Atk401515
DmitryRein00000000
Thutmose IIIMarch300000303030
Henry VBasic30101000can’t attach Atk502525
Harald IIIBasic300000can’t attach Atk3055
GnarrMarch350000353535
Elizabeth IBasic150000Ranged Atk -15%151530
Cyrus the GreatMarch150000151515
Li ShiminBasic1500100March Size can
attach Lv4 only
252525
Edward the Black PrinceBasic250000Mounted Atk -15%can’t attach Atk25015
Gwanggaeto the GreatBasic200000202020
Winfield ScottBasic250000252525
JumongBasic350000can’t attach Atk351010
Vladimir the GreatBasic200000All type Atk -15%202060
Gustavus AdolphusBasic150000Ranged Def -15%
Siege Def -15%
151545
Matthias IMarch200050252525
HimikoBasic1515000Mounted Atk -25%303055
AntaraBasic350000can’t attach Atk351010

A-2) Basic skills + Specialty + Covenant

Mainly for players with heavy payer.

For those who want to compare by the maximum value of assistants buffs.

1. Marcus Agrippa

  • Score: 265
  • Attack 125% / Defense 95% / HP 45% / March Size 0% / Rally Size 0%
  • Score: 240 (No Covenant)
  • Attack 110% / Defense 90% / HP 40% / March Size 0% / Rally Size 0%

2. Mihai

  • Score: 225
  • Attack 110% / Defense 95% / HP 20% / March Size 0% / Rally Size 0%

3. Godfrey of Bouillon

  • Score: 216
  • Attack 95% / Defense 45% / HP 70% / March Size 6% / Rally Size 0%
  • Score: 206 (No Covenant)
  • Attack 90% / Defense 40% / HP 70% / March Size 6% / Rally Size 0%

4. James Conrad

  • Score: 210
  • Attack 80% / Defense 55% / HP 75% / March Size 0% / Rally Size 0%

5. Maarten Tromp (when SvS)

  • Score: 200
  • Attack 120% / Defense 40% / HP 40% / March Size 0% / Rally Size 0%

Table (A-2) March/Rally – Basic Skills + Specialty + Covenant

GeneralsBuff
Type
AtkDefHPMarch
Size
Rally
Capacity
DebuffSkillbook
Limit
Covenant
Buff
Score
1
Score
2
Score
3
Godfrey of BouillonBasic95457060Included216216216
IdunnOutcity
Def
65202060111111111
Marcus AgrippaMarch125954500Included265265265
Louis IXBasic110852060can’t attach Atk221196196
MihaiMarch110952000225225225
SubutaiBasic105653060can’t attach Atk206181181
Maarten Tromp
(at SvS)
March120404000200200200
Maarten TrompMarch100204000160160160
EleanorMarch1055510100180180180
DouglasMarch86401060142142142
Douglas
(+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
March101551060172172172
Douglas (+Skin
+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
March111551060Ground Def -20%
Mounted Def -20%
182182222
Charles XIIMarch1054020100175175175
Mason WeaverBasic80102000110110110
Mason Weaver
(+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
Basic80354500160160160
Edward IIIBasic90253500150150150
James ConradMarch80557500All type Def -10%210210250
Princess KaguyaMarch91254560167167167
TomyrisMarch901045010155155155
Simeon the GreatMarch8145060132132132
Simeon the Great (+Dragon)March9645060147147147
Alfred the GreatMarch95201060131131131
ElektraMarch71102060107107107
Elektra (+Dragon)March91102060127127127
WallensteinMarch91010015116116116
Toyotomi HideyoriBasic50304000All type Atk -10%120120160
Minamoto no YoshitsuneBasic55102000can’t attach Atk856060
Minamoto no Yoshitsune
(+Dragon)
Basic116102000can’t attach Atk146121121
DmitryRein20201000All type Atk -10%505090
Thutmose IIIMarch7630000106106106
Henry VBasic76201000can’t attach Atk1068181
Harald IIIBasic60202000All type Atk -10%can’t attach Atk10075115
GnarrMarch8601000969696
Elizabeth IBasic55201060Ranged Atk -40%9191131
Cyrus the GreatMarch410060474747
Li ShiminBasic612636160March Size can
attach Lv4 only
139139139
Edward the Black PrinceBasic71104600Mounted Atk -15%
All type HP -10%
can’t attach Atk127102157
Gwanggaeto the GreatBasic66301060112112112
Winfield ScottBasic86100100106106106
JumongBasic61161000All type HP -10%can’t attach Atk8762102
Vladimir the GreatBasic50102060All type Atk -20%
Ground HP -10%
Mounted HP -10%
8686186
Gustavus AdolphusBasic4101600Ranged Def -15%
Siege Def -15%
575787
Matthias IMarch500050555555
HimikoBasic25151000Ranged Atk -26%
Mounted Atk -51%
All type Atk -10%
5050167
AntaraBasic45101000can’t attach Atk654040

B) for Reinforce to an ally’s city & Wall Defender

= Without Marching Buffs. (Reference: Buff / Debuff – Basic Guide)

When a reinforcement to “Alliance member’s City”, or a wall defender, the “marching buff” (“when General is leading the army to attack” buff) is disabled.

NOTE: When a reinforcement to “Building”, the “marching buff” is enabled. See section A.

Reinforcement to an alliance member’s keep

B-1) Basic skills only

1. Idunn

  • for Reinforce & Building Defense
  • Score:115
  • Attack 45% / Defense 35% / HP 35% / March Size 0% / Rally Size 0%
  • for Wall Defender
  • Score:45
  • Attack 45% / Defense 0% / HP 0% / March Size 0% / Rally Size 0%

2. Godfrey of Bouillon

  • Score:90
  • Attack 40% / Defense 10% / HP 40% / March Size 0% / Rally Size 0%

3. Mason Weaver (+Spiritual Beast)

  • Score: 70
  • Attack 20% / Defense 25% / HP 25% / March Size 0%

4. Louis IX

  • Score: 60
  • Attack 40% / Defense 45% / HP 0% / March Size 0%
  • Can’t attach Attack Skill Book.

5. Subutai

  • Score: 55
  • Attack 40% / Defense 20% / HP 20% / March Size 0%
  • Can’t attach Attack Skill Book.

Table (B-1) Reinforce/Defender – Basic Skills only

GeneralsBuff
Type
AtkDefHPMarch
Size
DebuffSkillbook
Limit
Score
1
Score
2
Score
3
Godfrey of BouillonBasic4010400909090
Idunn
(for Rein & Building Def)
Outcity
Def
4535350115115115
Idunn
(for Wall Defender)
Outcity
Def
45000454545
Marcus AgrippaMarch0000000
Louis IXBasic404500can’t attach Atk856060
MihaiMarch0000000
SubutaiBasic4020200can’t attach Atk805555
Maarten Tromp
(at SvS)
March0000000
Maarten TrompMarch0000000
EleanorMarch00010101010
DouglasMarch0000000
Douglas
(+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
March0000000
Douglas (+Skin
+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
March0000Ground Def -20%
Mounted Def -20%
0040
Charles XIIMarch00010101010
Mason WeaverBasic20000202020
Mason Weaver
(+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
Basic2025250707070
Edward IIIBasic251500404040
James ConradMarch0000000
Princess KaguyaMarch0000000
TomyrisMarch0000000
Simeon the GreatMarch0000000
Simeon the Great (+Dragon)March15000151515
Alfred the GreatMarch0000000
ElektraMarch0000000
Elektra (+Dragon)March20000202020
WallensteinMarch0000000
Toyotomi HideyoriBasic2010100404040
Minamoto no YoshitsuneBasic25000can’t attach Atk2500
Minamoto no Yoshitsune
(+Dragon)
Basic40000can’t attach Atk401515
DmitryRein30000303030
Thutmose IIIMarch0000000
Henry VBasic3010100can’t attach Atk502525
Harald IIIBasic30000can’t attach Atk3055
GnarrMarch0000000
Elizabeth IBasic15000Ranged Atk -15%151530
Cyrus the GreatMarch0000000
Li ShiminBasic150010March Size can
attach Lv4 only
252525
Edward the Black PrinceBasic25000Mounted Atk -15%can’t attach Atk25015
Gwanggaeto the GreatBasic20000202020
Winfield ScottBasic25000252525
JumongBasic35000can’t attach Atk351010
Vladimir the GreatBasic20000All type Atk -15%202060
Gustavus AdolphusBasic15000Ranged Def -15%
Siege Def -15%
151545
Matthias IMarch0005555
HimikoBasic151500Mounted Atk -25%303055
AntaraBasic35000can’t attach Atk351010

B-2) Basic skills + Specialty + Covenant

1. Idunn

  • for Reinforce & Building Defense
  • Score: 311
  • Attack 100% / Defense 100% / HP 105% / March Size 6% / Rally Size 0%
  • for Wall Defender
  • Score: 95
  • Attack 55% / Defense 20% / HP 20% / March Size 0% / Rally Size 0%

2. Godfrey of Bouillon

  • Score: 226
  • Attack 90% / Defense 50% / HP 80% / March Size 6% / Rally Size 0%
  • Score: 196 (No Covenant)
  • Attack 80% / Defense 40% / HP 70% / March Size 6% / Rally Size 0%

3. Louis IX

  • Score: 186
  • Attack 100% / Defense 85% / HP 20% / March Size 6%
  • Can’t attach Attack Skill Book.

4. Subutai

  • Score: 171
  • Attack 95% / Defense 65% / HP 30% / March Size 6%
  • Can’t attach Attack Skill Book.

5. Mason Weaver (+Spiritual Beast)

  • Score: 160
  • Attack 110% / Defense 35% / HP 45% / March Size 0%

Table (B-2) Reinforce/Defender – Basic Skills + Specialty + Covenant

GeneralsBuff
Type
AtkDefHPMarch
Size
DebuffSkillbook
Limit
Covenant
Buff
Score
1
Score
2
Score
3
Godfrey of BouillonBasic9050806Included226226226
Idunn
(Rein & Building Def)
Outcity
Def
1001001056311311311
Idunn
(Wall Defender)
Outcity
Def
5520200959595
Marcus AgrippaMarch3025150Included707070
Louis IXBasic10085206can’t attach Atk211186186
MihaiMarch6550200135135135
SubuaiBasic9565306can’t attach Atk196171171
Maarten Tromp
(at SvS)
March3010200606060
Maarten TrompMarch3010200606060
EleanorMarch30201010707070
DouglasMarch160106323232
Douglas
(+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
March160106323232
Douglas (+Skin
+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
March160106Ground Def -20%
Mounted Def -20%
323272
Charles XIIMarch30201010707070
Mason WeaverBasic8010200110110110
Mason Weaver
(+Dragon or Spiritual Beast)
Basic8035450160160160
Edward IIIBasic9025350150150150
James ConradMarch1020200All type Def -10%505090
Princess KaguyaMarch4625156929292
TomyrisMarch3010200606060
Simeon the GreatMarch161006323232
Simeon the Great (+Dragon)March311006474747
Alfred the GreatMarch5520106919191
ElektraMarch2010206565656
Elektra (+Dragon)March4010206767676
WallensteinMarch660100767676
Toyotomi HideyoriBasic5030400All type Atk -10%120120160
Minamoto no YoshitsuneBasic5510200can’t attach Atk856060
Minamoto no Yoshitsune
(+Dragon)
Basic11610200can’t attach Atk146121121
DmitryRein6620260All type Atk -10%112112152
Thutmose IIIMarch463000767676
Henry VBasic7620100can’t attach Atk1068181
Harald IIIBasic6020200All type Atk -10%can’t attach Atk10075115
GnarrMarch510100616161
Elizabeth IBasic5520106Ranged Atk -40%9191131
Cyrus the GreatMarch26006323232
Li ShiminBasic2501016March Size can
attach Lv4 only
515151
Edward the Black PrinceBasic7110460Mounted Atk -15%
All type HP -10%
can’t attach Atk127102157
Gwanggaeto the GreatBasic5630106102102102
Winfield ScottBasic5110010717171
JumongBasic6116100All type HP -10%can’t attach Atk8762102
Vladimir the GreatBasic4010206All type Atk -20%
Ground HP -10%
Mounted HP -10%
7676176
Gustavus AdolphusBasic25000Ranged Def -15%
Siege Def -15%
252555
Matthias IMarch30005353535
HimikoBasic2515100Ranged Atk -26%
Mounted Atk -51%
All type Atk -10%
5050167
AntaraBasic4510100can’t attach Atk654040

Related – Other Recommended Generals

Overall
List of Best Generals

Recommended generals are summarized by role, such as battle-oriented and development-oriented.

Recommended Main Generals

For a detailed look at each type of troops, click here.

Recommended Assistant Generals
List of All Generals
List of Generals by Role (+ How to Get)

A comprehensive list of all golden historic generals, over 100 in total, by role.

SHARE

If you found this article useful, I would appreciate a donation.

It will encourage me to update the site.

21

21 Comments

Anonymous

hi, very thorough job! it seems like you count all buffs/debuffs and march size equally in your evaluation. would some of them not be more important than others depending on the case? for example, for rally/march should attack buffs and march size not be more valuable than hp or defense? also, should hp not be more valuable than defense in all cases, and should march size not be extra important? should an imbalance between buffs, like really low defense, not count against the value of the general? so, isn’t the ranking kind of vague? thanks for all the work.

Anonymous

Hi can you suggest a good assistant general with Assistant general with Alfred the great

Hi, I always check out this page it really helped me a lot and this time I want yo about new general Eleanor how is her performance when she is assist. I can’t find anything about that in this page if you reply this it would be your kindness 🤗

Hello! I don’t think Mihai should be in the list of reinforcers, as his buffs are “leading the army to attack”. Thanks!

i need some help here, i have Minamoto with dragon and i don´t know which assitant fit better from him, his already 4red stars, but i can figure if is better maeson or Gnarr 1red star or Maeson 1red star as assitan for Minamoto, Gnarr give more attack % and Maeson give more HP%, Please help.

Mehmed II seems to be missing from the table – would he be good considering debuffs?

hey, i noticed that you dont include the marchsize increase e.g. charles xii gives – is this intentional or didnt you find a got metric to include it so far? (i basically am trying to compare charles with kaguya as assistant for Electra. Kaguya wins in terms of buffs, but including marchsize, i think charles is actually stronger)

Andrealphus

The attack of Mason Weaver while she is with a dragon or a beast is +25% and not +20

I had read that dragons and spiritual beasts don’t activate for assistant generals. If that’s the case, it changes the rankings drastically. For example, I had been planning to use Mason Weaver as an assistant for Minamoto before I learned this, but without the boost she would get from a spiritual beast…her base skill is the same as Gwangaetto

This is not entirely true. She doesn’t get the buffs and debuffs that the beast brings, but as an assistant general those skills you refer to will still activate if she brings a beast.

Please I need assistance general for my Gnarr for range attack.

Hermano y que hay del equipamento? Los equipos de Dragon etc. ambos generales pueden tener el mismo?

Anonymous

I am always interested in seeing your work.
Regarding the new Toyotomi Hideyori, how is he a good match for Simeon as an assistant?
Please let me know.

Anonymous

The ranking of the main archer general is also likely to change dramatically depending on how well the assistant works.🫤

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

The maximum upload file size: 35 MB. You can upload: image. Drop files here

If you found this article useful, I would appreciate a donation.

It will encourage me to update the site.



The copyright and other intellectual property rights of the game screenshots and images used in the contents of this site belong to TOP GAMES Inc.
This site provides content created independently by evonyguidewiki.com.
Unauthorized use or copying and replication (including translation into other languages) of the data, images, etc. on this site is strictly prohibited.